Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts

BOOK REVIEW: Paolo Bacigalupi's The Windup Girl

 

Paolo Bacigalupi's The Windup Girl is regarded as some as the most celebrated science fiction debut novel of all time. It was published in 2009 and has won the Nebula award, tied for the Hugo award for Best Novel, the John W. Campbell Award, and the Locus Award for Best Debut Novel.

The Windup Girl is considered an excellent example of a new genre of speculative fiction called "biopunk." Biopunk is a new term derived from cyberpunk science fiction and generally involves detailing the dangerous impacts of the biotechnology revolution on the near-future development of mankind. Bacigalupi had already made a notable name for himself by writing multiple award-winning short stories which contain many of the same themes which appear in this debut novel.

Similar to my experience with the other 2010 Hugo Award-winner for Best Novel, The City & The City, I really wanted to like this book but my actual experience of reading the book was less enjoyable than the enthusiastic reviews would have lead me to expect.

After reading the very first chapter I told my Other Half, "I don't think I'm going to like this book as much as the critics did."

My main problem with the book was my lack of connection with any of the main characters. Those were: Emiko (the eponymous windup girl of the title; she is a genetically modified humanoid--known as New People-- who has been engineered for absolute obedience); Hock Seng (a formerly very successful Chinese industrialist who is a refugee from an ethnic purge of Chinese people in Malaysia; he is known as a "yellow card" in Thailand due to his questionable immigrant status in the country); Anderson Lake (a secret representative of the multinational corporation AgriGen known as a "calorie man," he is currently the owner to Hock Seng's operations manager at a factory which produces "kink-springs";) Jaidee and Kanya (they are two "white shirts" who are employed by the Environment Ministry as somewhat arbitrary enforcers of strict environment regulations).

One of the central threads of the novel's plot is a political power struggle between General Pracha, the head of the Environmental Ministry, and the head of the Trade Ministry, Akkarat to control the city of Bangkok. The other main thread involves how (and whether) Emiko the windup girl will survive her dismal and desperate existence in Thailand. When we meet her, she is basically a sex slave who is being abused nightly for the entertainment and pleasure of men by another female employee. Because of her nature, Emiko can't refuse any request or order, regardless of how depraved or humiliating it is. Hock Seng is scheming to steal the plans for a revolutionary kink-spring in his boss Anderson Lake's safe in order to restart his career. Jaidee and Kanya (who is a secret mole for Akkarat) are pawns in the power struggle between Environment and Trade.

The most notable aspect of The Windup Girl is the alternate-history world view that Bacigalupi presents. In his vision, there has been an environmental catastrophe (Bangkok is literally under sea level, but is being protected by huge sea walls). Additionally, multinational corporations have their own private armies and regularly release genetically modified produce whose seeds can dominate and make sterile the indigenous produce of other nations. The currency of this new world is "calories." Most electric energy appears to be generated by kinetic energy, by turning "kink-springs" which can translate motion into power used to run machines. Of course, humans and animals get their energy to move from calories they eat. So, the corporations that control food production now control the world. It's an engaging and fascinating vision and Bacigalupi conveys it well. It's all the other aspects of a good book which seems to have eluded him: interesting (possibly sympathetic) characters in unusual situations with compelling conflicts and motivations. I was interested in the milieu the characters were in, but could care less what happened to the careers.

The primary defect of the book is the character of Emiko, the windup girl. It is just insupportable to re-create gender-based subordination in the form of what is essentially a real, live sex doll and not expect some people to object. Bacigalupi basically punts on the implication of his characterization of Emiko, even when he compounds it by layering on a Japanese name and explicitly giving her a bac story of being  a discarded plaything of a Japanese businessman who left her in Thailand because he didn't feel it was worth it to pay for Emiko to travel back to his country.

The way the stories are left somewhat unresolved makes it very likely that there will be a sequel to The Windup Girl but I doubt it will be a book I will feel is worth my time.


Title: The Windup Girl.
Author: Paolo Bacigalupi.
Length: 361 pages.
Publisher: Nightshade Books.
Date: September 15, 2009.

PLOT: B.
IMAGERY: B+.
IMPACT: B+.
WRITING: A-.

OVERALL GRADE:  B+ (3.33/4.0).

MOVIE REVIEW: The Fighter


Finally saw David O. Russell's The Fighter starring Mark Wahlberg, Christian Bale, Amy Adams and Melissa Leo in the week between Christmas and New Year's Day.

The Fighter tells the true story of Micky Ward, a Boston-Irish boxer whose (half)brother Dicky Edlund was a marginally successful but is now primarily coaching and training his younger brother while unsuccessfully trying to hide his crack addiction from his brother and mother. Micky is played by Mark Wahlberg and Dicky is played by Christian Bale. Their mom (and manager) Alice is played by Melissa Leo and Micky's girlfriend and future wife Charlene (played by Amy Adams).

The Fighter is animated by incendiary performances. The first of these is Bale's transformation from handsome, muscular hero (Batman begins, The Dark Knight) to a gaunt, hyperactive, confused drug addict. It is a harrowing performance to watch. ("Just give him his Oscar now" I whispered to my Other Half on the way out of the theater.) The flip-side of Bale's Dicky is Wahlberg's Micky. Although Wahlberg is the lead actor and presumably the eponymous fighter referred to in the title, Micky's lot in life resembles a follower, not a fighter. He basically does whatever his brother or mother tell him to do, and only slowly does he begin to realize that their wishes may not be parallel to his best interests. Wahlberg's performance is quiet and self-effacing where Bale's is flashy and unforgettable. Leo's Alice and Adams' Charlene are relatively similar in tone and appearance: strong, willful women with rough (and somewhat repellent) exteriors.

Although boxing is a 1-on-1 gladiatorial sport, in The Fighter most of the fighting (or squabbling) is done in threes: Micky and Charlene versus Dicky, Dicky and Alice versus Micky, Micky and Dicky versus the World, and Micky and Charlene versus his entire family. As you can see, many of these fights are between family members and are fraught with the intense emotions that can arise in those situations.


Overall, all boxing movies come into the world in which Rocky and Raging Bull have influenced the audience. The Fighter is a worthy addition to that oeuvre, and with the depiction of family dynamics and the excellence of the acting, the movie should be viewed favorably with the great family dramas (Ordinary People and Dangerous Liaisons).

Title: The Fighter.
Running Time: 1 hour, 54 minutes.
MPAA Rating: R for language throughout, drug content, some violence and sexuality.
Release Date: Friday, December 10, 2010.
Attendance Date: Thursday, December 30, 2010.

Plot: B.
Acting: A+.
Visuals: A-.
Impact: A-.

Overall Grade: A- (3.667/4.0).

BOOK REVIEW: Stephen Carter's PALACE COUNCIL

Stephen Carter's novel Palace Council is the third in his series of "Darker Nation" mysteries. The first were The Emperor of Ocean Park and New England White, both of which I have read and reviewed previously on this blog.

I liked both of Carter's previous mysteries (although I must confess a preference for the first, simply because of the multiple chess references) and haven't picked up his fourth work of fiction, Jericho's Fall, because it is in a completely new genre which I am uninterested in (spy thriller).

Palace Council is not as good as it's two predecessors. This time, instead of a straightforward murder mystery with a pinch of political intrigue and family drama in the mix, Carter has decided to write a faux historical novel.


The two main characters are Aurelia Treene and Eddie Wesley. Aurelia marries Kevin Garland, who is the son of "perhaps the richest Negro in the United States" in the 1950s. The Garland family played central roles in Carter's first two books. Eddie is in love with Aurelia, but he's also a dedicated writer. He ends up with two National Book Awards before he's 40 and a wanderlust which has him interacting with all the major characters of the era, including Joseph P. Kennedy, Richard Nixon, Edgar Hoover, Langston Hughes and many more.


However, the problem is that Carter has lost focus on what made his first two "Darker Nation" novels so interesting: they were centered around the Darker Nation! This idea is a clever concept that African-Americans have created their own, parallel social strata and power structures in America which are entangled  but distinct from the white hierarchy which rules America. It is Carter's mordant portrayal of this Darker Nation which animates his other novels and its absence in Palace Council leads to a plodding tale.


I do hope that Carter returns to his previous setting in future mysteries; for now, I would only recommend reading Palace Council for completeness. Otherwise just stop at reading The Emperor of Ocean Park and New England White, the first two in the series.


Title: Palace Council
Hardcover: 528 pages.
Publisher: Knopf.
Published: July 8, 2008.

OVERALL GRADE: B.

MOVIE REVIEW: Waiting for 'Superman'


Finally saw the acclaimed documentary Waiting for 'Superman'. It was showing at my favorite second-run theater, the Regency Academy 6 in Pasadena ($2 for a matinee, $3 other times). As an educator myself and someone interested in reforming mathematics education (especially 8th grade algebra) I had heard that this was a must-see film, and I was not disappointed.

Waiting for 'Superman' is the film which provoked the greatest emotional impact on me this year. It made me cry with despair and it made me gasp and groan with shock and disappointment. In the year of films with $100 million visual effects budgets, the most suspenseful moment I experienced in a movie theater in 2010 was waiting for a lottery ball to drop and reveal whether a student had been selected by random drawing for a slot in a public charter school!

The movie follows the educational hopes of five multicultural children, Daisy (a Latina 5th grader in East Los Angeles), Francisco (a Latino 1st grader in The Bronx), Anthony (a Black 5th grader in Washington, DC), Bianca (a Black kindergartener in New York City, NY) and Emily (a white 8th grader in Redwood City, CA). Each of these kids has engaged parents(or caregiver)  who have inculcated a love of education in their charges. However, the school uses an array of facts and figures to demonstrate that in order to improve their chances in life they will need to get a superior education, and in order to do that they will need to change what  schools they are going to. However, the decision of what school a child gets to attend in America depends on a number of things, and the primary thesis of the film is that the most important factor in the decision is luck. Either luck in being born to parents who have the resources to send you to private school, or the resources to buy a house in  a school district with good public schools. If you are not lucky to have been born to rich parents then you need the luck of the draw to win the lottery for admission to a public charter school that is committed to insuring that all their students have a good education and a better future.

The director, David Guggenheim, is already an Oscar winner for An Inconvenient Truth, and decided to tackle the issues of education reform when he realized that he was driving by numerous public schools on the way to dropping his kids off at at their private school.

Some would question the director's motives and are upset by the depiction of teachers' unions (American Federation of Teachers and National Education Association) as the primary impediment to meaningful education reform and the lionization of controversial Washington, D.C. superintendent Michelle Rhee and charter schools KIPP and Harlem Children's Zone. But I think people who dismiss the film for these reasons are missing the point; what Guggenheim's movie is trying to point out is that the American education system is  "about the adults" instead of being "for the children." And until that prioritization is corrected (and hopefully reversed) education is not just "other people's problem" it is all of our concern.

Title: Waiting for 'Superman'
Running Time: 1 hour, 42 minutes.
MPAA Rating: PG for some thematic material, mild language and incidental smoking.
Release Date: Friday, September 24, 2010.
Seen: Tuesday, December 28, 2010.

Plot: A+.
Acting: N/A.
Visuals: A-.
Impact: A+.

Overall Grade: A/A+ (4.11/4.00).

BOOK REVIEW: Alastair Reynolds' Absolution Gap

Alastair Reynolds' Absolution Gap is the third novel in his Revelation Space series. I was turned on to his work by Mark Chitty's Walker of Worlds blog, who is also a big fan or Peter F. Hamilton and Neal Asher, two other big British science fiction writers.

I read the first book in the Revelation Space series in Fall 2009 but have been eagerly devouring all of Reynolds works since then. See my reviews of the first two books in the trilogy, Revelation Space and Redemption Ark. In addition, there are two other novels which are set in the Revelation Space universe, Chasm City and The Prefect, both of which are excellent, well-written science fiction novels.

Surprisingly, even though Reynolds is most well-known for his original trilogy of novels set in the Revelation Space universe, they may not actually be his greatest creations.

Absolution Gap is the third and concluding book in the trilogy and features all the characteristics we have come to expect from Alastair Reynolds: dense, multi-layered plot(s), ambiguously identities of main characters, political intrigue, relativistic suspense and vast quantities of prose.

There is a 20-year gap between the events from the end of Redemption Ark and the events from the beginning of Absolution Gap. Our main protagonists Neil Clavain, the Conjoiner who defected to join Humans, Scorpio, a human-pig genetic hybrid, Ana Khouri (the main character from  Revelation Space and Redemption Ark), Skade (head of the Conjoiners and arch-nemesis of Clavain) all return and interact in ways on the planet Ararat which are exciting and horrifying (not everyone survives and I don't want to give away any spoilers here). It is nice to see characters that we are familiar with re-appearing in this third and final book of the series.

As with his other books in the Revelation Space series, the sophisticated plot of Absolution Gap also unspools in multiple time periods, due to Reynolds' insistence on no space flight greater than the speed of light combined with events that occur in different star systems.

The new characters that Reynolds introduces are terrifying and fascinating. On the planet Hela, Rashmika Els is a teenaged girl who apparently always knows when someone is telling the truth. Hela is ruled by the clearly insane Quaiche, who is a former crewmember of the Ultra spaceship Gnostic Ascension, and Grelier another crewmate who acts as Quaiche's right-hand man and enforcer. Quaiche has been infected with an indoctrination virus which makes him obsessed with Hela's star, Haldora, which appears to disappear intermittently (for fractions of a second every decades or so). He has had his eyelids removed and placed himself in a cathedral in perpetual motion so that he can (literally) keep his eyes constantly on Haldora so he doesn't miss a single vanishing. Rashmika goes to work for Quaiche and Grelier since someone with her unusual talents are invaluable.

The two storylines from Ararat and Hela intersect when the "lighthugger" Nostalgia for Infinity leaves Ararat (the Inhibitors are destroying that planet's star and are only prevented from destroying the planet itself by Clavain's old Conjoiner friend Remontoire) and everyone goes to Hela for the resolution of the story. It turns out the mystery behind Haldora's bizarre disappearing act is the existence of another alien species who may be able to help humans in the fight to stave off extinction, or who may be even worse than The Wolves.

Overall, although Absolution Gap is not as gripping as the first two installments of the trilogy, it is a reasonably high-quality conclusion to an incredibly original, well-written space opera which can be favorably compared to any of the classics in the genre of hard science fiction.

Author: Alastair Reynolds.
Title: Absolution Gap.
Length: 768 pages.
Publisher:
Ace.
Date:
May 31, 2005.

OVERALL GRADE: B+ (3.4/4.0).

BOOK REVIEW: Peter F. Hamilton's The Evolutionary Void

 

Peter F. Hamilton's The Evolutionary Void is the third (and final) book in the British science fiction grandmaster's Void Trilogy which started with The Dreaming Void and The Temporal Void. I was looking forward to reading this book very much and even purchased the hard copy on Amazon.com months prior to its official publication.


Hamilton is well-known for his long, intricately plotted, hard sci-fi space operas which are peopled with a dizzying number of characters. The Evolutionary Void is no exception, and it is even more complicated than his other books because it is not only the culminating work in the Void Trilogy, it also follows his earlier Commonwealth Saga books Judas Unchained  and Pandora's Star.

The Evolutionary Void picks up exactly where The Temporal Void concluded. There are multiple storylines which are instantaneously resumed which requires the reader to get up to speed very quickly. In fact, it is probably impossible to read and enjoy this book without reading the first two books (The Temporal Void and The Dreaming Void) first, and relatively recently.

The main story lines are bifurcated into action that takes place either inside or outside the Void, a spatial anomaly which can potentially expand to eliminate the known Galaxy. Inside the Void, the main character is Edeard the Waterwalker who lives in the curiously exogenous city-state of Makkathran which possesses a pseudo-feudal political structure with very limited technology but is populated with humans having telekinetic and telepathic powers. Outside the Void, 1200 years have passed since the exciting events depicted in Hamilton's Judas Unchained  and Pandora's Star. Many of the main characters from those books (Paula Myo, Ozzie Isaacs, Nigel Sheldon, Gore and Justine Burnelli and Oscar Monroe come to mind) are still around, and if you haven't read the previous duology then the reader will miss some nuances of these characters' interactions. The people outside the Void know about the goings on inside through Dreams which are shared in the gaiasphere, a galactic-wide network where properly equipped humans can share their emotional states (invented by Ozzie, of course!) with everyone. Only two people have ever been able to dream about events happening (or that have happened?) within the Void: Inigo (The First Dreamer, around whom a powerful religion called Living Dream has been formed) and the unknown Second Dreamer, who is only identified (and publicly exposed after a multi-planet manhunt) as an average Commonwealth citizen named Araminta. Araminta is a great creation, again demonstrating Hamilton's deft approach with female characters; just as Paula was the heroine of the first series, Araminta is the heroine of the second.

For someone whose reputation is built (deservingly so) on his depiction of action-packed, explosion-filled space battles and mind-blowing, futuristic technology, Hamilton does a surprisingly compelling job of telling what is essentially a fantasy tale inside the Void involving Edeard. The fantasy bits are the best part of the Void books, in my opinion. Hamilton's actually used this device of interlaced chapters of fantasy and hard science fiction before, in Fallen Dragon, and it works very very well. In fact, when the fantasy section becomes somewhat irrelevant due to an ill-chosen plot device I will not give away here, the science fiction story did not hold my attention nearly as well as my previous interest in Edeard's story and as a result I lost interest in The Evolutionary Void. This really surprised me, but it's undeniable that at some point I was just simply confused and slogging through the out-of-the-Void story, anxiously looking forward to catching up on Edeard's story inside-the-Void. When all I could look forward to was whatever Paula, Araminta, Oscar or Inigo would do next, my attention and interest flagged.

This is not to say that The Evolutionary Void is a bad book; Hamilton is an incredibly ambitious author and I think he just tried to do too much in one ridiculously large novel. (Really, the three Void books are clearly just one gigantic tale that due to the constraints of the publishing industry had to be released as three separate volumes.) This is also not surprising because Hamilton's masterwork, The Night's Dawn Trilogy, which is hands-down the best science-fiction trilogy ever written, was released as no less than 6 different books when really it is one gargantuan tale. I have to confess even reading that work one can get lost, but there the problem was that one had too many plot threads and characters one cared about. Reading the Void trilogy we have precisely the inverse problem: too few characters we care about--even characters that we had previously cared about quite a bit in the earlier duology. Of the new characters, only Araminta and Inigo are really fully drawn, with the primary villain of the piece recycled from the earlier series (The Cat). I think there was just one more hook (mystery, romance, comedy, horror) which if it had been included would have greatly strengthened my overall evaluation of this final book, and by extension the entire series. I have read both The Night's Dawn trilogy and Judas Unchained & Pandora's Star twice in their entirety; I believe I would rather re-read those than the Void trilogy (although I will probably give The Evolutionary Void another read, just for completeness).

There is still a lot of science fiction out there I have not read, such as Hamilton's own Misspent Youth, which is a standalone novel set around 1500 years before The Void Trilogy. If any of it is as creative and compelling as this sub-par (by his superlative standards!) Hamilton novel, I will be happy indeed.


Author: Peter F. Hamilton.
Title: The Evolutionary Void 
Hardcover: 704 pages.
Publisher: Del Rey. 
Date: 
August 24, 2010.







PLOT: A-.
IMAGERY: A-.
IMPACT: B+.
WRITING: A-.


OVERALL GRADE: (3.583/4.00) B+/A-.

MOVIE REVIEW: The King's Speech


Finally saw The King's Speech, the latest Oscar-bait ("Based on the incredible true story") from The Weinstein Company. It is directed by Tom Hooper, starring the crème de la crème of British acting talent (Colin Firth as King George VI, Helena Bonham Carter as Queen Elizabeth, Timothy Squall as Winston Churchill, Michael Gambon as King George V) as well as some renowned Australian actors (Geoffrey Rush and Guy Pearce).

The King's Speech is widely seen as a front-runner for the 2010 Best Picture Oscar, with Firth garnering kudos from almost every critics group under the sun and building a convincing claim that last year's Best Actor nomination for A Single Man was merely a precursor to a win this year. Rush, who already has a Best Actor statuette for Shine, is generating buzz for a supporting Oscar, but it looks like Christian Bale's work in The Fighter may have that category wrapped up.

It's hard to evaluate the film outside the context of the annual Oscar race, especially considering the Weinsteins' history and the caliber of the actors involved. Hooper is a well-regarded but youthful British direct most well-known for the HBO miniseries John Adams which starred Paul Giamatti and Laura Linney and won a boatload of Emmys last year.

The King's Speech is about the story of an unorthodox Australian speech therapist named Lionel Logue who worked with the Duke of York (the King's second oldest son) to try to correct a severe stammer and a concomitant paralyzing fear of public speaking. Firth does a heart-wrenching job of portraying the agony of a chronic stutterer. Since, he is second-in-line for the throne, Firth's character (called Bertie by his friends and family) has many, many opportunities (and obligations) to give public speeches and the film depicts the way time seems to stand still as Firth labors to produce coherent and articulate sounds. In addition to the personal journey of Bertie to overcome what appears to be an insurmountable disability, the film also is leavened with suspense as the political intrigue thickens as Bertie's brother becomes King, making Bertie next in line. Of course, the problem is that if Bertie becomes King then of course he will have even more obligations to speak publicly.

Overall, the film depicts pre-World War II era London impeccably. Firth's performance, along with Bonham Carter's clever turn as his consort and Rush's attempt to steal scenes are the main reasons to see the film. Although it is hugely entertaining and captivating, I did n;t leave the film thinking "Wow, that was a reallly good movie" which is how I did feel when I walked out of Toy Story 3, Inception, The Kids Are All Right and The Social Network.

Title: The King's Speech.
Running Time: 1 hour, 51 minutes.
MPAA Rating: R for some language.
Release Date: Friday, November 26, 2010.
Seen: Tuesday, December 21, 2010.

Plot: B+.
Acting: A.
Visuals: A-.
Impact: A.

Overall Grade: A- (3.75/4.0).

MOVIE REVIEW: 127 Hours


The husband and I saw Oscar-winning director Danny Boyle's 127 Hours at our usual theaters in Alhambra recently. 127 Hours is the follow-up to his multiple Oscar-winning Slumdog Millionaire  (Best Picture, Director, Adapted Screenplay, Cinematography, Editing, Sound Mixing, Score and Song) stars James Franco in the incredible true story of Aron Ralston. Ralston is the guy who went hiking in a Utah canyon without telling anyone where he was going and after a freak accident left him trapped under a boulder was forced to cut off half of his own right arm in order to escape after nearly 5 days (127 hours) with minimal food and water.

127 Hours is currently rated 93% positively on rottentomatoes.com, one of top-rated movies of 2010. Franco is also stating to garner multiple notices from critics for his riveting performance in the film.

Initial marketing of the film concentrated on the audience reaction to the graphic nature of the scene where Franco's character saws off his own arm with a dull knife in order to escape his entrapment under a boulder in a canyon crevice. More recently, Fox Searchlight has started marketing a "I Kept My Eyes Open For 127 Hours" website, button and t-shirt campaign to rebrand the intense film experience as a rite of passage (or possibly indication of machismo) for some filmgoers.
Actually, I don't think I could wear the t-shirt because although I may have kept my eyes open for the entire
film, I was definitely squirming in my seat during the scene where Franco's character starts to cut into his own flesh. Director Danny Boyle does an incredible job of really placing the audience in the position of Aron Ralston. You really do feel like you are trapped in that canyon with James Franco, which is an amazing feat of immersive filmmaking.

The visuals and impact of the film are the most impactful of any film that I have seen all year. You are filled with immense respect and admiration for Aron Ralston and it really makes you question what you would do in a similar situation.


127 Hours really makes you think about the limits of human endurance and marvel at the power of film in the hands of a gifted filmmaker and a fully committed actor.

Title: 127 Hours.
Running Time: 1 hour, 33 minutes.
MPAA Rating: R for language and some disturbing violent content/bloody images.
Release Date: Friday, November 5, 2010.
Seen: Sunday, December 11, 2010.

Plot: B+.
Acting: A.
Visuals: A+.
Impact: A+.

Overall Grade: B+ (4.0/4.0).

Survivor: Nicaragua Review: "Fabio" Edges Chase 5-4 To Win

Jud "Fabio" Birza (left) and Chase Rice

After happily finishing all my grading for the Fall 2010 semester I was able to relax las night by watching the finale of Survivor: Nicaragua, where 21-year-old "surfer dude" Fabio went up against "dumb but pretty" Chase and "sexually ambiguous strategic mastermind" Sash. The last member of the final four was the last remaining woman, Holly, who became the last member of the 9-person Jury who would decide which of the Final 3 would win $1 million and the title of Sole Survivor.

I was actually pretty happy with any of the final three winning but would have been happier if Chase had won (mostly because he was the hottest guy on the show!) As soon it was revealed that Fabio (whose actual name was Jud but because of his persona he was renamed on Day 1 and it stuck) had won the million dollars by a  vote of 5-4 he immediately demonstrated himself to be a spacey, anti-intellectual dreamer. My immediate reaction was "This is the guy you all wanted to win a million bucks?" Chase is attempting to have a country music career and has a decent voice. He should be a success since he is now a household name already.

I was disappointed Sash did not get any votes from the 9 person jury. He was the person in control of the game for the longest period of time, which means that he was the person responsible for the most people getting kicked off. This should demonstrate his ability to outwit the most people, but it is human nature to resent and want to punish the person who was responsible for their inability to win the million dollars and they will use their remaining power to make sure you don't. What people don't realize is that EVERYONE but the final three have to be kicked out at some point, the problem is that every person on the jury thinks that THEY should have been in that final 3, which is simply self-delusional.

Fabio was considered too dumb to be a threat for the majority of the game. As Sash pointed out, there were many many Tribal Councils where Fabio had no idea who was going to be voted out and thus was in the minority or joined the majority  at  the last moment. (One could make the argument that this strengthen's Fabio's case for winning since because he was not responsible for anyone's departure, more people would view him positively). What people over-looked was that he was very young and in reasonable shape so as the numbers got smaller and smaller (around 6 or 5) he was able to win three Individual Immunity challenges in a row (the last three) which cemented his position to appear before the Jury and plead his case for the Million Dollars.

Chase was in the "in-group" for the entire game but because the in-group (the majority which decides who gets voted out) is very flexible and generally changes from week to week. However, instead of managing this dynamic nature in a calm, unflappable fashion (like Sash) Chase repeatedly is shown agonizing over decision and constantly talking to members of the tribe, trying to find out if he himself was on the chopping block. Multiple people called him "paranoid." I do think Chase had the better back story (his father had died recently and he announced he would donate $100,000 towards cancer research if he won) and used his southern roots to connect with the most popular member of the Survivor: Nicaragua cast, Jane and small-town denizen Holly.

Interestingly, according to Wikipedia the deciding vote was cast by the "villain" of this season's cast, NaOnka, who actually gave Chase her immunity idol when she controversially decided to quit the show.
Somehow she changed her mind and decided Fabio (who she despised throughout the entire season) deserved the million dollars. I think it is more likely the table below here is incorrect and Naonka's and Alina's votes are switched.

Jury Vote[citation needed]
Finalist:Sash
0/9 votes
Chase
4/9 votes
Fabio
5/9 votes
JurorVote
HollyChase
DanFabio
JaneChase
BenryFabio
Kelly S.Fabio
NaOnkaFabio
BrendaChase
MartyFabio
AlinaChase

I thought the Reunion show was atrocious. It didn't get into the specifics of the vote when it was a ONE vote decision! If anyone changed their mind it could have altered the final winner. Jeff Probst was short and scattered and didn't provide a context in which more information about the Survivor Cast could be revealed. The one interesting question was the reveal that Brenda had turned on Sash (Brenda and Sash had controlled the game together for at least half the game when she was blindsided and became the third member of the jury). Sash had had an immunity idol at the time and it was always curios that when he knew Brenda was about to go that he had not given her the idol to save her. Instead time in the reunion was used to let Holly give millionaire businessman Dan (who because he was so physically feeble he was kept to the final 5 because everyone knew they would win $1 million if he was in the Final 3) some expensive shoes since she had ruined his shoes on the show.

The next Survivor will also be in Nicaragua and will fundamentally alter the game, now when people are voted off they will be able to come back to the game if they win a challenge between rejects. I think this is a really bad idea.

I do like that the producers announced that if people quit the show they will no longer be guaranteed to be on the Jury. If they quit the show, they should be immediately removed from all aspects of the show, regardless of how telegenic and entertaining they are (see Naonka).

All-in-all this was one of the better seasons of Survivor even if there were no openly gay castmembers, there was substantial eye candy (Chase) and Fabio was consistently amusing as well.

MOVIE REVIEW: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1


Saw the 7th Harry Potter film on Thanksgiving weekend, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1.

As someone who read all seven of the Harry Potter  books, had the last book delivered to my house on the day of release by amazon.com and read the entire 784-page book that weekend, I had high hopes for the movie adaptation (especially since Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is the best book of the series).

Ultimately I was disappointed with this movie because I thought it focussed far too much on the bleak aspects of the book. Since the last book (and movie) are wrapping up an intricate, immense tale I expected lots of action in the film adaptation. There are several storylines that need to get resolved before the conclusion of the film series. That's not to say that the film is not exciting and gorgeous to look at, but its more of a mature film, since the Hogwarts school is no longer the primary setting for the story (or film).

The basic story is that the most powerful (and evil) magician of all-time named Lord Voldermort killed Harry Potter's parents when he was a child but for some reason could not kill baby Harry. Voldemort vanished from the scene soon after but he is the most feared magician of all time and throughout the first books was more well-known as "He Who Shall Not Be Named." The first four books are about the growing realization that Voldemort's supporters (called Death Eaters) are successfully working to return The Dark Lord to power. We discover that Voldemort has split his life essence into seven pieces called "horcruxes" in order to make himself nearly-immortal but that something went wrong the day he tried to kill Harry Potter and he nearly destroyed himself. Throughout the latter part of the series we have been slowly exposed to these horcruxes and to date two have been destroyed in the process of various adventures.

*SPOILER ALERT*

One more horcrux gets destroyed in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1, but that means there are four more horcruxes that need to be found (and hopefully destroyed) in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 2 which is released July 15 2011. And the searches for the horcruxes are just the main trunk of the story, which has many many branches and offshoots (romance between Harry and Ginny Weasley, romance between Harry's two best friends Hermione Granger and Ron Weasley, determination of Severus Snape as good or evil, the fate of Hogwarts and revenge for Dumbledore's death, just to name a few).

* END OF SPOILER ALERT*

There is so much story in the final book it seems odd that there is so little story developed in Part 1, which will make Part 2 chock-ful (maybe too full) of plot and resolutions. Part 1 does an excellent job of depicting the baleful middle passage of the book where it is clear that Harry, Hermione and Ron are on their own battling against the forces of the Dark Lord which are ascendant. We do find out what the deathly hallows are (they happen to include objects which showed up in the earlier books: The Resurrection Stone, The Invisibility Cloak and the Elder Wand), which is important, and Ron and Hermione solidify their relationship but that's about it. Some more (mostly) minor characters die, which is possibly foreshadowing that characters may die in the final installment.

Interestingly, Part 1 has generally been well-accepted by audiences (88% positive) but not so much by critics (79% positive) and has grossed $257 million in 24 days of release. It will probably end up just behind Inception  (#5 at 292 million) for the 6th highest grossing movie of 2010. Part 2, I suspect will almost certainly be the top box-office film of 2011, even with Thor, Captain America, Pirates of the Caribbean IV, Mission Impossible IV and Transformers 3 in competition during the summer.

I will most definitely be seeing the conclusion of the Harry Potter series on opening weekend next summer.

Title: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1.
Director: David Yates.
Running Time: 2 hours, 30 minutes.
MPAA Rating: PG-13 for some sequences of intense action violence and frightening images.
Release Date: November 19, 2010.
Seen: Sunday, November 28, 2010.

Plot: B.
Acting: A-.
Visuals: A.
Impact: B.

Overall Grade: B+ (3.417/4.0).

MOVIE REVIEW: The Town


I finally saw the film The Town directed by Ben Affleck which has a 94% rating at rottentomatoes.com while I was in Washington, D.C. on a business trip at the Ballston Mall.

The Town is a surprisingly good film, starring Affleck as Doug MacRay, the brains behind a gang of bank robbers in Boston, Massachusetts. In fact, a statement at the beginning of the movie claims that the Charlestown section of Boston (i.e. "The Town") has the most bank robbers and armored car robbers per capita of any community in the country. Also starring in the film are Jeremy Renner (Oscar nominated for last year's The Hurt Locker), Jon Hamm (star of television's Mad Men) and Rebecca Hall (The Prestige, Vicky Christina Barcelona). The film also features Oscar-winner Chris Cooper (Adaptation) as Doug's father, Stephen MacRay.

The plot is interesting and features excellent performances, primarily by Renner, Affleck and Hamm.. The story is a pastiche of a romantic drama featuring Hall and Affleck, a heist thriller with several scenes of numerous bank robberies executed like clockwork, and a cop procedural featuring Hamm and "the feds" as they trace Affleck and his brotherly gang of thieves. This is not  meant as a critique, but a fair description to illustrate Affleck's creativity as a writer. However, it as a director that Affleck really makes his mark. The Town moves swiftly, in an engrossing fashion. Although it is sometimes preposterous, and often quite violent, it is never boring.

Running Time: 2 hours, 4 minutes.
MPAA Rating: R for strong violence, pervasive language, some sexuality and drug use.
Release Date: September 17, 2010.
Seen: Sunday, November 14, 2010.

Plot: B+-.
Acting: A-.
Visuals: A-.
Impact: B+.

Overall Grade: A- (3.50/4.0). 

MOVIE REVIEW: The Social Network


The Social Network
 is more ubiquitously known as "The Facebook movie." This is odd, because although the movie does tell the story about the creation of what would go on to become the largest social networking website in the world in Fall 2003 in the dorm room of a 19-year-old Harvard undergraduate, it is really about Mark Zuckerberg the creator and current CEO of Facebook.

The movie is directed by the brilliant David Fincher (Fight Club, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Alien3) from a screenplay adapted by the equally renowned Aaron Sorkin (The West Wing, A Few Good Men) from a book called The Accidental Billionaires: The Founding of Facebook A Tale of Sex, Money, Genius and Betrayal.

The movie stars Jesse Eisenberg as Mark Zuckerberg, whom he plays as a fast-talking, emotionally distant computer genius. In fact, emotionally distant doesn't begin to describe Eisenberg's emotional affect as Zuckerberg in the film; he appears as clearly somewhere advanced on the Autism-Asperger's Syndrome axis.

Since the film makers are well aware that the audiences for the film will likely be on Facebook themselves they provide us with all the details of how a computer program essentially created in a single dorm became a worldwide cultural behemoth less than 7 years later.

Sorkin's screenplay cleverly intercuts between Zuckerberg being deposed in two separate lawsuits over the creation of Facebook, one from his erstwhile best friend Eduardo Saverin (a fellow Jewish student of Brazilian descent played by the attractive actor Andrew Garfield) and from Divya Narendra, Cameron Winklevoss and Tyler Winklevoss. The Winklevoss Brothers (who are 6'5", 220 lb, blond blue-eyed champion members of Harvard's crew team, played by a single actor Armie Hammer with his face digitally projected on a body double) and Narendra had plans to make a website called HarvardConnect which would allow Harvard students to interact with each other online. They approached Zuckerberg after he became famous on campus for nearly bringing down Harvard's network connection after he developed a website in one night, while drunk, which allowed Harvard students to rate female Harvard students on "hotness." Zuckerberg agreed but never produced any actual code for the Winklevoss twins, and instead started his own website with $1,000 in seed funding from his friend Saverin which he called "thefacebook.com." This is about as much of the plot as I want to reveal; suffice it to say it is worth watching, in the theaters, for yourself.

The film is an engrossing, well-told tale of how friendships and relationships can be destroyed by an overwhelming desire to be successful in business, and although Zuckerberg doesn't come out smelling like a rose for his interactions with both the Winklevoss twins and with Saverin, the film clearly demonstrates that Zuckerberg is the reason why Facebook is what it is today and in the word of Eisenberg's character scoffs at the notion that either of the groups suing him could have created anything similar.

It should be noted that Fincher, Sorkin and Zuckerberg have all declared The Social Network to be a work of fiction, but in some sense that makes the film even more entertaining.

Hopefully the film, as well as the work of Eisenberg, Fincher, and Sorkin will not be forgotten at end-of-year awards time. I fully expect this film to be high in my annual Top 10 list.

Running Time: 2 hours, 1 minute.
MPAA Rating: Rated PG-13 for sexual content, drug and alcohol use and language.
Release Date: October 1, 2010.
Seen: Sunday, October 24, 2010.

Writing: A+.
Acting: A+.
Visuals: A-.
Impact: A-.

Overall Grade: A (4.0/4.0).